2016 Metropolitan Opera National Council Auditions

I was able to attend the Metropolitan Opera National Council Auditions for young singers on 6 March (semi-finals) and finals on 13 March.  I have many good feelings but also some pragmatic comments that I think are necessary to share.   

Many of the singers were very young.  In fact, I was surprised how young the singers were.  I remember that the winners were usually around 30 years old or more.  Indeed, this is why the competition has an age limit of 32, I believe.  Why is this?  Because the older you are, the better singer you are.  Young singers show talent, but most young singers are not able to jump into a career, especially if they are in their early 20's.

The finals were very stressful for the nine finalists because they must sing with the MET orchestra, but get very little rehearsal.  I thought some of the singers were very polished in their presentation.  But here are some important points:

1.  Only three of the 9 finalists at this time had enough vocal potential to develop enough to 
     sing in a production at the MET.  Only one, the Korean baritone, had the voice now to 
     sing at the MET.

2.  Of the five winners, four had the basic languages necessary.

3.  Of the five winners, four had the basic style necessary.

I liked the Soprano who won, because she is on the verge of having a great voice and is only 24.  The Mezzo had no ringing sound in her voice, so if she develops, then she can be very good.  The young tenor showed polish and style, just needs time to develop.  The counter-tenor has a nice voice, almost big enough, and good style.

The Korean baritone was older and because of this his voice was more mature, but unfortunately his languages and style were bad both at the semi-finals and finals; he did not improve.  In a week, and in a competition of this type, you MUST improve, and eliminate mistakes.  If you can't do this, it shows that you are possibly not caring, or not smart enough.  People who run opera companies hear a voice like the baritone has, and they give him a chance.  But they usually only get one chance to do things right.

 This goes for all of us.  In the West, you don't get many second chances; you produce a quality product or you die, so to speak!